ANALYSIS | How sending patients farther away for long-term care will (and won’t) help Ontario’s hospitals | CBC News


Simply how dire is the scenario in Ontario hospitals? Premier Doug Ford’s authorities is keen to face the just about inevitable public blowback from sending seniors as much as 150 kilometres away for long-term care, all to unlock just a few hundred hospital beds. 

Beneath new rules that take impact subsequent Wednesday, hospital sufferers in southern Ontario awaiting spots in long-term care could be moved to nursing properties as much as 70 kilometres away, whereas for these in northern Ontario, the gap is 150 kilometres. 

The federal government is pitching this as a manner of easing the pressure on the hospital system, plagued this summer time by record long wait times and emergency room closures.

What’s not clear is how massive an affect the brand new guidelines for long-term care transfers will even have on the hospital crunch.

A key barometer of the pressure on the hospital system is the typical time an admitted affected person spends ready within the emergency room till they get a mattress on a medical ward. The latest statistics, launched this week by Ontario Well being, present that common wait hit an all-time excessive of 20.7 hours in July.   

One key cause for the backlog is Ontario’s hospitals have a report variety of sufferers who’ve been discharged by their medical doctors however are nonetheless occupying a mattress. These sufferers are usually ready for another well being care that is not obtainable, equivalent to long-term care, dwelling care or bodily rehabilitation.

Ontario Well being Minister Sylvia Jones proclaims that hospital sufferers awaiting spots in long-term care might be moved to nursing properties not of their selecting as much as 150 kilometres away, with prices of $400 per day in the event that they refuse. (Christopher Katsarov/The Canadian Press)

Greater than 6,000 such “alternate degree of care” (ALC) sufferers are in Ontario’s hospitals right now. Meaning roughly one in 5 hospital beds is taken up by somebody who does not really want acute care.

And that in flip results in different sufferers ready hours or days within the emergency room earlier than they will get admitted to a hospital ward, or delays in scheduled surgical procedures as a result of no post-op restoration beds can be found.       

So what number of of those 6,000 beds might be freed up by the federal government’s new guidelines on long-term care transfers?

It took asking the query thrice in three other ways, however Ontario’s Well being Minister Sylvia Jones ultimately revealed a goal. 

“We’re very hopeful and assured that we’re going to have the ability to have 400 alternate degree of care sufferers positioned in neighborhood,” she informed a information convention at Queen’s Park.   

4 hundred sufferers is just not an insignificant quantity but it surely solely scratches the floor of the issue.

The most recent statistics from Ontario Well being present the typical time an admitted affected person spent ready within the emergency room earlier than getting a mattress on a medical ward hit an all-time excessive of 20.7 hours in July. (Evan Mitsui/CBC)

“That is all a political present,” mentioned Tom Closson, a former chief govt of the Ontario Hospital Affiliation, on Twitter this week.

“There are virtually 40,000 individuals in the neighborhood on wait lists to get into nursing properties,” Closson added. “There are virtually no areas in any nursing properties for hospital ALC sufferers to be admitted into no matter how far these properties are away.”

Regardless of Closson’s dismissal of the brand new guidelines, some present hospital CEOs are welcoming the transfer, a part of the newly handed Bill 7, the federal government’s Extra Care, Higher Beds Act.

The federal government’s plan “will enhance affected person circulate, growing affected person entry to the specialised acute care our hospital supplies.” mentioned the CEO of the North Bay Regional Well being Centre, Paul Heinrich, in a statement.

“Invoice 7 will assist guarantee each mattress obtainable throughout the system is getting used correctly,” mentioned Heinrich. 

David Musyj, CEO of Windsor Regional Hospital, says the alternate degree of care phenomenon has troubled the health-care system since earlier than he began working in it, greater than 20 years in the past.

Windsor Regional Hospital CEO David Musyj says it took braveness for the Ford authorities to vary the foundations in order that sufferers could be transferred longer distances into long-term care. (CBC Information)

“Each single important political get together had a possibility to do one thing about this over the past twenty years, however none of them have till now,” mentioned Musyj in an interview with Radio-Canada. “So it took braveness to do what’s being finished now and I have to applaud them for it.”

Re-elected with a fair larger majority simply three months in the past, the Ford authorities has loads of political respiratory room to make probably unpopular choices, equivalent to sending seniors removed from dwelling for long-term care.

There is not any applause coming from the opposition New Democrats for the federal government’s transfer. 

“What this authorities is doing is to shuffle individuals round from one overextended system to a different, however it isn’t really going to resolve the issue that we’re seeing in our emergency rooms and our working rooms,” mentioned Peter Tabuns, the Ontario NDP’s interim chief, in a information convention at Queen’s Park. 

The federal government is just not really claiming the brand new long-term care switch guidelines alone will resolve every little thing. The issues are far too deeply entrenched and the bottlenecks too long-standing for one fast repair. 

For years, governments of all stripes squeezed hospital funding to the extent that Ontario has fewer beds per capita than all different provinces, in a rustic with fewer beds per capita than nearly every other wealthy nation

The Ford authorities is promising to create 30,000 new areas in long-term care by 2028. Most services are nonetheless within the pre-construction planning phases. (Michael Aitkens/CBC)

Layer on high of that the consequences of the pandemic — workers burnout, pent-up demand for delayed care, and a rising burden of sickness — and you’ve got Ontario’s present hospital disaster. 

The federal government’s response is a five-point plan that, along with the long-term care guidelines, features a push to deal with the backlog of greater than 200,000 scheduled surgical procedures by performing extra of them in private for-profit clinics.

How stand-alone surgical clinics might assist

The Ontario Medical Affiliation (OMA), which represents physicians, is proposing a barely completely different solution to ease the surgical backlog: creating “built-in ambulatory clinics,” stand-alone services for day surgical procedures, run on a not-for-profit foundation, partnered with hospitals reasonably than privately run. 

Day surgical procedures are procedures that may be carried out on an outpatient foundation, usually not requiring a affected person to be admitted to hospital in a single day. 

Proof from these in different provinces suggests they will carry out outpatient surgical procedures 25 per cent extra effectively than hospitals, says Dr. Jim Wright, an orthopedic surgeon and the OMA’s vice-president of economics, coverage and analysis. 

Dr. James Wright, a pediatric orthopedic surgeon and chief of the Ontario Medical Affiliation’s economics, coverage and analysis division. He says stand-alone services for day surgical procedures, run on a not-for-profit foundation, might assist resolve the issue. (Riziero Vertolli/OMA)

“The expertise worldwide is sufferers prefer it, the restoration is quicker, they usually discover it a way more streamlined expertise,” Wright informed a digital information convention this week 

Hospitals are best-placed for emergency and inpatient surgical procedures, mentioned Wright, whereas stand-alone clinics are far much less prone to postpone scheduled day surgical procedures as usually occurs to outpatients.

The speculation is that this is able to shift a few of the surgical burden away from hospitals, permitting them to focus their sources on acutely sick sufferers. 

However there is a catch: it is going to “optimistically” take 12 to 18 months to create these stand-alone clinics, mentioned Wright.

Whereas they might ultimately be a giant a part of the answer for Ontario’s hospitals, they cannot do something to ease the strain now, nor the even better strain that many within the well being system anticipate will come within the fall and winter, when contagious illnesses unfold extra simply and the affected person load usually grows. 


Leave a Comment