Experts warn that Canadian weapons shipped to Ukraine could end up in the wrong hands | CBC News


The danger of Canadian weapons shipments being misplaced, stolen or in any other case misused is rising because the warfare in Ukraine enters a chaotic and unsure new part.

And with shipments of Canadian weapons nonetheless because of arrive in Ukraine, some are warning that components of these shipments may find yourself on the black market or be turned towards the Ukrainian individuals by the Russian navy or native paramilitary teams.

“There’s the actual risk that the Ukrainian authorities can doubtlessly not management all of those weapons,” mentioned Kelsey Gallagher, a researcher with Challenge Ploughshares, a Canadian non-government disarmament group.

“They may find yourself wherever.”

Because the begin of the Russian invasion, Canada has pledged navy support to Ukraine valued in the tens of millions of dollars. The promised support consists of anti-tank techniques, rockets, handguns, machine-guns and ammunition.

These weapons are being supplied solely to Ukraine’s ministry of defence and its armed forces — however consultants say it is not possible to know for sure the place these weapons would possibly ultimately find yourself.

Whereas Russia has escalated its assaults throughout Ukraine in latest days, the Ukrainian navy has thus far managed to combat off Russian advances on most of its largest cities, leaving the end result of the warfare solely unsure.

“We can not exclude solely the likelihood that a few of that weaponry will find yourself within the incorrect arms,” mentioned Costanza Musu, a College of Ottawa professor specializing in worldwide safety.

Musu described how Western weapons shipments to Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia and Libya went lacking or had been misused previously.

Simply final yr, the Taliban seized stockpiles of U.S. weapons after the group overthrew the Afghan authorities.

The chaos that adopted the 2011 Libyan civil warfare resulted within the unfold of weapons throughout Africa. A few of these weapons went to the terrorist teams Boko Haram and al Qaeda by way of the black market, the United Nations has said.

What may occur to weapons in Ukraine?

There are various doable outcomes for the weapons being despatched to Ukraine by Canada and NATO allies, though almost all of them embody the danger of materiel going lacking.

“At any time when this battle does subside … these weapons aren’t simply going to go ‘poof’ and disappear,” Gallagher mentioned.

Russian President Vladimir Putin mentioned final week that he would welcome the donation of captured “Western-made” weapons to Russian-backed militant teams in Jap Ukraine.

“In fact I help the opportunity of giving these to the navy items of the Lugansk and Donetsk individuals’s republics,” Putin said on March 11.

The Kremlin particularly listed anti-tank techniques — which Canada is offering to Ukraine — among the many weapons that may very well be handed over to these teams. It isn’t clear if any Western weapons have been captured by Russia.

Russian President Vladimir Putin mentioned final week that he’ll provide captured Western weapons to the militaries of two breakaway areas in Jap Ukraine. (Mikhail Klimentyev/Sputnik/Kremlin Pool/The Related Press)

Gallagher additionally mentioned he worries about paramilitary teams now working in Ukraine, a few of them linked to far-right extremism.

“I do suppose that surging enormous quantities of weapons into Ukraine, the place there won’t be the capability to completely soak up them and to make sure that they are going into the arms they’re speculated to be going, may in the long term be a disservice to the Ukrainian individuals and civilians within the area,” he mentioned.

A drawn-out battle may additionally result in Canadian weapons turning up on Ukraine’s small-arms black market, described by the International Organized Crime Index as one of the largest in Europe.

What Canada is doing to maintain monitor of its weapons

In an announcement to CBC Information, the Division of Nationwide Defence mentioned solely that its navy donations to Ukraine “are managed with finish customers certificates supplied by the MoD of Ukraine.”

These certificates sometimes stipulate who’s allowed to make use of a weapon and for what. The federal government didn’t present particular particulars about these agreements.

Canada additionally has duties as a celebration to the Arms Trade Treaty, which governs the worldwide commerce in weapons. 

The treaty would require that Canada conduct a radical danger evaluation earlier than sending weapons to Ukraine. The federal government has not made public particulars of that course of, however consultants say it will have examined the opportunity of weapon shipments being diverted.

Musu mentioned Canada and Western allies appeared to succeed in the identical conclusion — that the necessity to assist Ukraine defend itself outweighs the danger of Western weapons being misused.

“There should not that many options,” Musu mentioned. “What most governments have felt is that the one factor they’ll do to shift the percentages somewhat bit … is to help Ukraine militarily.”


Leave a Comment