National Addiction Treatment Locator Has Outdated Data and Other Critical Flaws

At a psychiatric hospital in Michigan, Dr. Cara Poland’s sufferers have been handed a sheet of paper to search out follow-up care. The hospital had entered native ZIP codes on an internet site — run by the nation’s high substance use and psychological well being company — and printed the ensuing checklist of suppliers for sufferers to name.

However her sufferers who tried to make use of it typically hit a wall, Poland mentioned. They’d name a quantity solely to search out it disconnected, or they’d study {that a} facility wasn’t accepting new sufferers, or that the clinician had retired or moved.

“It’s scary, as a result of should you go to make use of the location, it’s acquired invalid info,” said Poland, an addiction-medicine physician who’s now an assistant professor in ladies’s well being at Michigan State College. “Folks hand over if they’ll’t discover remedy. And we threat shedding a life.”

The web site,, was launched by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration in 2019 to assist lots of of 1000’s of Individuals affected by habit reply a vital query: The place can I get remedy? It’s a listing of greater than 13,000 state-licensed remedy amenities, together with info on what forms of companies are supplied, which insurance policy are accepted, and what ages are served.

Clinicians, researchers, and affected person advocates welcomed the repository as a important first step to overcoming the fragmented habit remedy panorama and centralizing info for sufferers. Most thought of it a safer various to Googling “habit remedy close to me” and turning up potentially predatory marketers.

Nevertheless, the identical proponents say and SAMHSA’s different treatment locators have important flaws — inaccurate and outdated info, a scarcity of filtering choices, and little steerage on the best way to establish high-quality remedy — which can be lengthy overdue for consideration.

“It’s being handled as a gold-standard device, but it surely’s not,” Poland mentioned.

With overdose deaths reaching record highs, “we want to be higher,” mentioned Jonathan Stoltman, director of the Opioid Coverage Institute in Michigan. is the primary hyperlink that comes up on Google searches for rehab, he mentioned. In keeping with SAMHSA, a department of the U.S. Division of Well being and Human Companies, it receives almost 300,000 web page views a month. It’s the device many state and native helplines use when making an attempt to attach somebody to remedy.

“It’s essential to get this proper,” Stoltman mentioned.

SAMHSA spokesperson Christopher Garrett mentioned in an announcement that the company “endeavors to maintain the [tools] present.” If SAMHSA is knowledgeable of outdated info — reminiscent of an incorrect handle, phone quantity, or kind of service supplied — “we act upon that info,” he wrote. Such updates are made weekly.

As well as, SAMHSA surveys amenities yearly, utilizing the responses to replace, Garrett wrote.

Bradley Stein, director of the Rand Opioid Coverage Heart, mentioned enhancing the remedy locator can be useful, however a number of the criticism displays extra advanced underlying points — like the shortage of providers — that SAMHSA alone can not resolve.

“There’s going to be a restrict to its worth if in all places mainly has a ready checklist,” Stein mentioned.

However others say fixing the issues is central to the nation’s response to habit.

“It’s time to cease analyzing the opioid epidemic, ” mentioned Dr. Babak Tofighi, an internist at NYU Langone Well being who research how know-how can improve entry to remedy for substance use issues. As a substitute, he mentioned, funding must go towards assembly remedy demand.

He mentioned remedy locators not solely want to take care of correct info, but in addition ought to alter their fashions to permit individuals to do every thing in a single place: find out about habit, analysis remedy suppliers, and enroll in care seamlessly.

Even small motion in that path may make a giant distinction, mentioned Hendrée Jones, govt director of the College of North Carolina’s Horizons substance use remedy program for girls and their kids. SAMHSA collects knowledge on which amenities serve pregnant and postpartum sufferers, she mentioned, but doesn’t permit customers to filter by these classes. Altering that would profit a number of the patients who struggle most to search out care.

Maybe the most important enchancment clinicians and public well being specialists need to see on is an indicator of a facility’s high quality. Presently, customers can filter by kind of remedy — detox, inpatient, outpatient — and whether or not a facility presents drugs for opioid use dysfunction. However the website doesn’t point out which forms of care are extra doubtless to achieve success — although the federal authorities funds analysis on that topic. SAMHSA has a minimal vetting course of for the amenities displayed, requiring solely that they full a survey and be licensed of their state.

Researchers and public well being specialists say this will lead sufferers to spend 1000’s of {dollars} on ineffective remedy and even predatory amenities. A study published last year discovered that lots of of residential applications on SAMHSA’s web sites have been admitting individuals for pricey remedy — typically encouraging them to enter debt — with out assessing whether or not they actually wanted that stage of care.

Frank Greenagel, a medical social employee in New Jersey who focuses on habit remedy, mentioned counting on state licensure is misguided as a result of many state companies check only a facility’s paperwork, which might checklist counseling or different companies even when they have been by no means really supplied.

Garrett, the SAMHSA spokesperson, mentioned within the assertion to KHN that the company trusts state well being departments and different accrediting our bodies to deal with subpar amenities. The assertion additionally mentioned choices about remedy ought to ideally be made between sufferers and their physicians.

Different non-public and public remedy locator instruments have popped as much as fill in a number of the gaps on, although specialists say they’ve their very own shortcomings.

The nonprofit Shatterproof developed a web-based useful resource called ATLAS, which measures facility high quality. The web site, which at the moment gives info on six states, contains affected person critiques and asks suppliers to report whether or not they meet sure “indicators of high-quality care,” reminiscent of providing same-day appointments, offering drugs for opioid use dysfunction, and providing particular person counseling.

In 4 of these states, Shatterproof makes use of insurance coverage claims knowledge to trace how typically amenities implement finest practices, mentioned Shannon Biello, vp of remedy high quality and technique for ATLAS. Though that knowledge shouldn’t be seen publicly, amenities can entry it privately and see how they examine with others of their state.

Affected person advocates hope the platform will information individuals to simpler care and encourage amenities to enhance their practices. However in addition they fear concerning the group’s skill to go nationwide and maintain a multimillion-dollar challenge.

In Ohio, one household took on the job of making a remedy locator for the state.

Jennifer Ayars, 28, died of a drug overdose in 2016 earlier than existed. (Invoice Ayars)

Invoice Ayars misplaced his 28-year-old daughter, Jennifer, to a drug overdose in 2016. On the time, didn’t exist. Ayars merely had a pocket book wherein the household had written names of amenities they’d referred to as to get Jennifer assist. He needed to offer different households a greater place to begin.

In 2017, alongside along with his then-fiancée, youthful daughter, and some employed employees members, Ayars launched a remedy locator website. It will definitely listed 1,200 habit remedy suppliers throughout Ohio and garnered greater than 200,000 guests. It was featured on the state psychological well being and habit company’s web site, printed on the discharge papers of a serious hospital system, and listed on flyers distributed by syringe service applications.

“We felt excellent that we stuffed a niche,” mentioned Ayars, of Cleveland.

But it surely was a big elevate. Ayars’ fiancée and staffers typically spent 12 hours a day calling amenities and updating their info each six months. The challenge price greater than $100,000 a yr, he mentioned.

So when SAMHSA launched, Ayars retired the site his staff had constructed and directed guests to the nationwide useful resource as an alternative.

It’s for households like Ayars’ that it’s essential to enhance, specialists say.

“People who find themselves in search of assist deserve to search out rapid assist,” mentioned Jones in North Carolina. “Having a nationwide remedy locator that’s updated and simply searchable is a primary step in that restoration journey.”

This story was produced by KHN (Kaiser Well being Information), a nationwide newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about well being points. Along with Coverage Evaluation and Polling, KHN is among the three main working applications at KFF (Kaiser Household Basis). KFF is an endowed nonprofit group offering info on well being points to the nation.

Leave a Comment