The U.S. wants to ban Juul. Where is Canada on regulating e-cigarettes? | CBC News


Earlier this week, regulators in the US ordered Juul to drag its vaping merchandise from the market, dealing a significant blow to some of the highly effective gamers within the business.

The corporate is interesting the choice by the U.S. Meals and Drug Administration (FDA), asking a federal court docket to dam a authorities order to cease promoting its digital cigarettes.

Whereas the tried ban within the U.S. does not immediately have an effect on Canada, some well being advocates say it raises questions in regards to the sluggish tempo of regulation on this nation.

Here is a more in-depth have a look at the FDA’s determination and what’s occurring in Canada. 

Why was Juul banned?

As a part of the FDA’s assessment course of, corporations needed to show that their e-cigarettes profit public well being. In apply, meaning proving that grownup people who smoke who use them are prone to give up or cut back their smoking, whereas teenagers are unlikely to get hooked on them.

In its decision, the FDA mentioned that among the greatest e-cigarette sellers like Juul might have performed a “disproportionate” position within the rise in teen vaping. The company mentioned that Juul’s utility did not have sufficient proof to indicate that advertising and marketing its merchandise “can be applicable for the safety of the general public well being.”

On Friday, the e-cigarette maker requested the court docket to pause what it known as an “extraordinary and illegal motion” by the FDA that will require it to right away halt its enterprise. The corporate filed an emergency movement with the U.S. Courtroom of Appeals in Washington because it prepares to attraction the FDA’s determination.

That dispute is much from over. 

Juul merchandise are proven at a vaping retailer in New York in 2020. The FDA has ordered the corporate to halt the sale of its merchandise. (Marshall Ritzel/Related Press)

What about in Canada?

Juul’s vaping merchandise, in addition to these offered by different corporations, stay obtainable in Canada. 

Well being Canada proposed a ban on flavoured vaping merchandise last June. On the time, it cited analysis indicating that flavoured vaping merchandise are “extremely interesting to youth, and that youth are particularly vulnerable to the adverse results of nicotine – together with altered mind improvement, which may trigger challenges with reminiscence and focus.” 

However after a spherical of consultations final yr, that proposed ban nonetheless hasn’t been implement. 

WATCH | P.E.I. now has hardest vaping, smoking legal guidelines in Canada: 

P.E.I. now has hardest vaping, smoking legal guidelines in Canada

As of March 1, folks need to be 21 to purchase vaping or tobacco merchandise in P.E.I., giving the province the best age restrict within the nation.

A number of provinces and territories have put in place their very own limits on flavoured vaping merchandise, citing their attraction to youngsters.

(Juul voluntarily stopped promoting a lot of its flavoured cartridges in 2020 following criticism they had been designed to entice youth.)

David Hammond, a public well being professor on the College of Waterloo who researches vaping in youth, mentioned banning Juul merchandise within the U.S. will not essentially have a major influence on the business as an entire, given its declining market share and the number of merchandise obtainable.

“You realize, it is like a tube of toothpaste. If you happen to press at one level, you simply sort of squeeze it to a unique spot,” he mentioned.

What does Well being Canada say?

“Well being Canada has no plans to take away any vaping merchandise from the Canadian market that adjust to the Tobacco and Vaping Merchandise Act and the Canada Client Product Security Act,” the company instructed CBC Information in an electronic mail.

The federal government has lately put in place new restrictions on the sector, together with limits on promoting for e-cigarettes and the quantity of nicotine within the merchandise. It is additionally present process a assessment of the laws for vaping merchandise that went into impact in 2018.

On its web site, Well being Canada warns of the dangers of e-cigarettes, saying “the potential long-term well being results of vaping stay unknown” and the federal government continues to analyze “extreme pulmonary sickness related to vaping.”

Last week, Well being Canada introduced one other set of proposed laws that will require vaping corporations to reveal details about “gross sales and elements utilized in vaping merchandise,” to assist the federal government “hold tempo with the quickly evolving vaping market.”

How common is vaping?

Vaping is common amongst younger folks, with 14 per cent of Canadians between the ages of 15 and 19 having vaped within the final month of 2020, up from six per cent from the identical month in 2017, in keeping with the outcomes of the Canadian Tobacco and Nicotine Survey.

Vaping is much less common for adults over the age of 25, with simply three per cent reporting that they vaped inside the final month in 2020.

Robert Schwartz, a senior scientist at Toronto’s Centre for Habit and Psychological Well being, mentioned the regulatory problem is to strike a stability between making these merchandise obtainable to adults as an alternative choice to cigarettes, whereas on the identical time limiting their attraction to youthful non-smokers.

“We positively are discovering that younger individuals who wouldn’t in any other case grow to be cigarette people who smoke have began to make use of e-cigarettes they usually pretty shortly develop a dependence on them,” mentioned Schwartz.

“Our analysis can be demonstrating that some adults are in a position to give up by … utilizing these cigarettes.”

What is the holdup?

Like Schwartz, Hammond mentioned vaping merchandise might be a useful gizmo in serving to wean people who smoke off cigarettes. He mentioned it does not make sense to place strict limits on vaping merchandise if cigarettes, that are considered extra dangerous, are nonetheless obtainable in nook shops. 

Dr. David Hammond is a public well being professor on the College of Waterloo who researches vaping amongst youthful folks. (Craig Chivers/CBC)

“I do not assume the reply lies simply with how they’re regulated,” he mentioned. “I feel it lies with the business and reframing these merchandise as one thing {that a} 50-year-old makes use of to give up smoking and never a 15-year-old grabs on the way in which to a celebration.”

Hammond, who sits on Well being Canada’s advisory board for vaping merchandise, mentioned the company might stand to maneuver extra shortly given the stakes.

“There is not any doubt these are tough questions and the market shifts quickly. But it surely’s not an space the place sluggish, plodding regulation is an efficient match,” he mentioned.

Cynthia Callard, govt director of the advocacy group Physicians for a Smoke-Free Canada, mentioned that, whereas the context is completely different in Canada, the FDA determination “is a reminder that governments can and will bar market entry to merchandise which can’t be proven to profit public well being.”

Leave a Comment