Why mask mandates likely wouldn’t solve the crisis in children’s hospitals | CBC News


That is an excerpt from Second Opinion, a weekly evaluation of well being and medical science information emailed to subscribers. If you have not subscribed, you are able to do that by clicking here.


  • Rising calls to reinstate masks mandates aren’t being heeded by well being officers. 

  • However what influence would masks mandates throughout Canada even have on the surge of RSV and flu straining youngsters’s hospitals? 

  • Not all viruses are the identical and mandating masks now could be more durable to justify. 


Masks are an efficient layer of safety within the struggle towards COVID-19 and have been important all through the pandemic, serving to to forestall an infection, gradual transmission and make crowded indoor environments safer when used appropriately.

However whereas everybody is inspired to put on a masks to guard themselves in sure conditions throughout respiratory sickness season, mandating them now could be more durable to justify for a variety of causes. 

Not a single provincial and territorial chief medical officer within the nation has opted to make using masks obligatory once more, regardless of rising public stress and calls from some media and front-line physicians for masks mandates to alleviate the pressure on hospitals.

The highest medical doctors in British Columbia, Ontario, Quebec, Alberta, Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Prince Edward Island and Newfoundland and Labrador have all mentioned now shouldn’t be the time to reinstate masks mandates, however proceed to advocate masks to gradual viral unfold.

The query is, what influence would widespread masks mandates throughout Canada even have on the surge in respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) in children and the rapid return of the annual flu season presently overwhelming youngsters’s hospitals in a lot of the nation?

WATCH | Provinces resist rising stress for return of masks mandates:

Well being consultants are pushing for masking in public as respiratory diseases surge, however provinces together with Quebec, Alberta and B.C. are resisting requires renewed masks mandates.

“It is actually not clear as a result of RSV is being transmitted primarily in daycares and in younger youngsters and there we do not need to have masks mandates,” mentioned Dr. Caroline Quach-Thanh, a pediatric infectious illnesses specialist at Montreal’s Sainte-Justine youngsters’s hospital and the previous chair of the Nationwide Advisory Committee on Immunization (NACI).

“We would like youngsters to have the ability to develop and form of dwell a standard life as a lot as doable,” she added.”What you actually should do is lower your variety of contacts and make it possible for while you’re sick, you keep away. And if you cannot keep away, then you definitely put on a masks.”

Not all viruses are the identical

Masks mandates performed a major function in stopping the unfold of COVID-19 and to a big extent the flu over the previous two years, together with far more excessive measures reminiscent of lockdowns, journey restrictions, faculty closures and the shuttering of indoor companies.

Dr. Lynora Saxinger, an infectious illnesses doctor and affiliate professor on the College of Alberta in Edmonton, mentioned the influence masks have on transmission is usually exhausting to tease other than different public well being measures that had been performed on the similar time.

“If everybody used wonderful masks routinely, there’s this concept that we might haven’t any bother and I do not suppose that is true, I do not suppose that is supported by the proof,” she mentioned.

“However I do suppose that they’ll have a job in lowering transmission that could possibly be necessary, and that the time is at all times higher earlier somewhat than later. You do not need to put them in when the horse is effectively and actually out of the barn.”

Masks mandates are heavy-handed public well being measures that had been extra justifiable with a brand new virus previous to the event of COVID-19 vaccines and coverings, however not all viruses are the identical and COVID levels have stabilized or dropped throughout the nation. 

“It is not going to have the identical influence. It is not that it is a zero influence, however wouldn’t it be as impactful with RSV because it was for COVID? Most likely not,” mentioned Dr. Amesh Adalja, an infectious illness doctor on the Johns Hopkins Heart for Well being Safety in Baltimore.

“One of the simplest ways to get a deal with on RSV within the present scenario is ensuring that youngsters, once they’re sick, they’re staying house. However each respiratory virus shouldn’t be going to be amenable to the identical issues that work for COVID.”

Adalja mentioned there are additionally points with youngsters sporting masks, together with their capability to put on them correctly and the match of the masks, along with the very fact that youngsters usually tend to get contaminated with RSV by touching surfaces after which their faces.

Masks mandates performed a major function in stopping the unfold of COVID-19 and to a big extent the flu over the previous two years, together with far more excessive measures reminiscent of lockdowns, journey restrictions, faculty closures and the shuttering of indoor companies. (Evan Mitsui/CBC)

RSV additionally transmits in another way than different viruses, Quach-Thanh mentioned, pointing to a 1981 study in the Journal of Pediatrics that instructed RSV primarily spreads via shut contact, droplets and surfaces.

“It is an enchanting examine exhibiting that transmission by [surfaces] happens, nevertheless it doesn’t rule out transmission by aerosol particles at short-range,” mentioned Linsey Marr, an professional within the airborne transmission of viruses and an engineering professor at Virginia Tech in Blacksburg, Va.

She added that as a result of the examine was performed in a hospital, a spot that’s normally well-ventilated, the chance of aerosol transmission might need been lowered.

RSV additionally impacts adults and kids in another way, with a 2015 study in the Journal of Clinical Microbiology suggesting speedy antigen assessments for RSV have “poor sensitivity” in adults which will make them ineffective — as a result of they shed a lot much less virus than children.

“Masks in all probability have some influence on RSV transmission, nonetheless, RSV transmission is probably going occurring largely from children-to-children and floor transmission is essential for RSV in a means that it’s not for COVID,” mentioned Adalja.

“So adults sporting masks, it is in all probability not going to have the identical influence on RSV transmission as a result of it is not likely adults giving it to youngsters, it is youngsters giving it to youngsters … I do not suppose that we’ve to deal with every thing as if it is COVID-19.”

Marr mentioned masks mandates would in all probability assist cut back the variety of circumstances of flu.

“Through the first yr of the pandemic, when individuals had been distancing and masking, there was nearly no flu. The measures we had been taking towards COVID-19 had been very efficient for the flu,” she mentioned. “For RSV, the impact of a masks mandate is not as clear.”

SARS-CoV-2, influenza and RSV are all completely different beasts and utilizing masks mandates as a one-size-fits-all resolution to the disaster in youngsters’s hospitals could also be an oversimplification that ignores the alternative ways these viruses unfold and the age teams they hit hardest.

WATCH | Strain on youngsters’s hospitals prompts requires return of masks mandates

Calls mount for return of masks mandates because of surge of sick children

Some are calling on governments to reimpose masks mandates to gradual the unfold of respiratory diseases and cut back the stress on youngsters’s hospitals, that are seeing an inflow of RSV, the flu and COVID all of sudden, resulting in longer wait instances and a few cancelled surgical procedures.

“Infants are most in danger from RSV, they usually cannot put on masks, in fact. Infants get the virus from individuals round them, and if these individuals masks, there could be much less RSV on the air and on surfaces,” Marr mentioned. 

“Infants could be uncovered to much less virus and could be much less more likely to turn into contaminated. So in concept, a masks mandate may assist cut back circumstances of RSV, however there’s much more uncertainty concerning the magnitude of the impact.” 

Extra instruments to struggle unfold of viruses

One factor that RSV and influenza have in frequent is that they are much extra critical for infants and the aged, however in contrast to RSV, we’ve extra instruments in our toolkit towards the flu — knowledge exhibits we simply do not use them broadly sufficient.

Lower than 40 per cent of Canadians opted to get a flu shot in 2020, in response to the newest federal data, regardless of being beneficial and obtainable for everybody older than six months outdated. 

“Flu is rising at a very quick price proper now, and youthful children are at greater danger of great illness if contaminated with flu,” mentioned Dr. David Naylor, co-chair of the federal authorities’s COVID-19 Immunity Process Power. “Sadly, uptake of flu vaccine in youngsters stays low.”

In Alberta, barely greater than 27 per cent of the inhabitants received a flu shot final yr, and thus far simply 15 per cent of Albertans have rolled up their sleeves this yr — with infants, toddlers and youngsters effectively beneath 10 per cent protection. 

“There isn’t any vaccine for RSV,” mentioned Naylor. “However accelerating flu vaccines within the very younger and really outdated is essential.”

There are RSV vaccines in the works and there’s hope one could possibly be obtainable within the close to future, and Sanofi and AstraZeneca introduced the European Commission authorized a one-dose RSV drug known as nirsevimab earlier this month.

“That is going to be necessary. That is one thing that Canada ought to have and the U.S. can have as effectively finally,” mentioned Adalja. “After which possibly by subsequent season, we’ll have RSV vaccinations focused to high-risk adults and pregnant girls.”

The speedy surge of RSV and flu in Ontario youngsters’s hospitals is showing early signs of slowing down, with the variety of five- to 17-year-olds presenting to hospitals with respiratory signs dropping from 1,134 on Nov. 9 to 824 on Nov. 16.

“Pediatric hospitals at all times get hit with RSV yearly. It was normally a winter illness. Right here it appears to be a fall illness, and we appear to be having an earlier low season enhance,” mentioned Adalja. 

“Whether or not that is going to be extra extreme or not, I feel we have to see, nevertheless it’s clear that each baby by the age of three will get RSV.”

WATCH | Is it time to carry again masks mandates?:

Is it time to carry again masks mandates? | Fast Query

Dr. Barry Pakes, York Area Medical Officer of Well being, and Dr. Fahad Razak, former head of the Ontario Science Desk, focus on whether or not public well being officers ought to carry again masks mandates to forestall hospitals turning into overwhelmed with a triple-whammy of respiratory diseases.

However the drop in hospital visits for newborns to four-year-olds has been less pronounced, with the seven-day common all the way down to 1,110 from a peak of 1,263 on Nov. 11, and provinces like Nova Scotia and Quebec are nonetheless seeing an unprecedented surge of pediatric sufferers.

“Masks are one device, however what you actually should deal with is defending probably the most susceptible and for RSV these are younger infants,” Quach-Thanh mentioned. 

“For those who ship through the winter, make it possible for whoever involves see the infant has zero signs by any means, and much more so, lower contacts with these infants — defend them, cocoon them. That is actually what we need to do.”

Leave a Comment